eBooks – are they all they’re cracked up to be?!

I was reading an article by Lucy Mangan in Stylist yesterday about e-readers and, well, her general distain for them. Now, I shall not reply the article in detail, but she makes a couple of points which made my ponder over my own relationship with my Kindle:

  • e-readers do not allow you to connect with a book in the way you do with a physical copy, recalling happy memories at a mere glance;
  • A physical book will not break or run out of battery in the middle of use.

If I am honest, these are both valid points and things I have mused over myself. Taking the second point first (just to be a bit ‘zany’), my Kindle has broken. When it broke, I was in the middle of a book. At the time, my response was ‘Argh’, followed by some moments of rage and general grumpiness. But, that said, I reported the problem to Amazon, they gave me lots of support and, when it was clear the problem was not to be fixed, they sent me a new one within 3 working days. In the interim, I went back to a standard book and also caught-up on my rowing magazine. Ultimately, I survived the ordeal! Charging doesn’t even warrant it’s own paragraph – the power consumption on a proper e-reader is so low that when you get a low battery warning, you still have a good few hours of reading before it dies.

So, the more crucial issue she raised, that you do not get attached to e-books. I whole-heartedly disagree with this. I do admit, I miss seeing the cover of a book, but having an e-reader has stopped me from picking my books based on the picture on the front which, lets face it, we have all done. Now I read the synopsis and the user reviews. I build an entire catalogues of books ready for my literary consumption. I take chances on new authors. Then, when I read, I get engrossed if the story is worthy of it. This is no different to when I read the print versions. No, I cannot look across my bookshelves and recall the happy memories, but I can flick through my Kindle and get the same thing from the titles. When I am reading a book, my Kindle becomes that book; when I recently read ‘The Hunger Games’ (see my review on Revado), I looked at my Kindle and all I could think was that I wanted to read the next bit – the emotion was exactly the same as my pre-Kindle days.

So, in summary, I’m afraid Lucy, I disagree with you. Of course everyone is entitled to their views (although I do think one should try something before completely writing it off) but I am a fan of an e-reader. There are numerous disadvantages (like the fact my library is now tied to Amazon), but the advantages are just too great and after one-too-many train journeys where I have finished my book before reaching Finsbury Park and then sat there bored, I am converted. It also makes the books that do deserve a physical presence on my shelf that bit more special!

Leave a reply:

Your email address will not be published.

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sliding Sidebar

About Me

About Me

Hello, I'm Angela. I'm Mum to two small people (4 & 1). I'm a Gardener, am houseplant obsessed and addicted to tea. By day I work in tech and also look after my littles. I'm trying to get our family to live a more sustainable life. I also have far too many opinions...hence the blog. You can read more about me here. You can also follow me on Twitter so you never miss a post. Hope you enjoy reading!

Browse the archives